How to make your own Pizza Sauce, easy pantry recipe.

Welcome to Our Sunday Café, we are pleased you stopped by for a visit. Today we are offering another delicious recipe from our kitchen. We hope you enjoy it as much as we did…

I like to do it myself, but I like being able to do it myself, even more.

We had homemade pizza for our dinner on Sunday. When I went to the pantry cupboard there was no tomato sauce. Around here tomato sauce is usually purchased as part of a recipe that is planned for, except for that lone can in wait for "those times" and apparently I had already used it! Not wanting to go back to the store a third time (yes twice, short story, I forgot the pizza cheese on the supplies list, for Pete's sake!), I improvised.

And as luck would have it, this turned out delicious and is now our preferred pizza sauce. It is worth the little bit of extra time, and the bonus? I always have cans of diced tomatoes, I could not get along without them. This sauce is flavorful with just the right touch of tomato goodness. This is also perfect to have on the stove while you are working on other kitchen chores, multi-tasking, it is a beautiful thing!

How to make Homemade Pizza Sauce. Easy pantry recipe.

Pantry Pizza sauce
by the seat of my pants

1 14.5 oz can diced tomatoes - do not drain
1 T sugar
1/2 t oregano leaves
1T basil leaves
1/4 t garlic salt
1 T olive oil

Empty tomatoes into a medium-sized saucepan.

Mash the tomatoes with a potato masher, to break up.

Add remaining ingredients, bring to a boil.

How to make Homemade Pizza Sauce. Easy pantry recipe.

Reduce heat to medium-low and simmer until thick, 30-45 minutes.

How to make Homemade Pizza Sauce, easy pantry recipe.

Homemade Pizza Sauce, from your pantry.
Pizza Sauce, homemade from your pantry.
 This is at the 15-minute mark. Just beginning to thicken.

This is done at 30 minutes. Thick enough to stay where the spoon pushes it!
This smells so good!

Now you're ready to make pizza. Choose your dough, along with your favorite flavors and bake!

Pizza is fun, easy to personalize and best of all delicious!


Thank you for visiting Our Sunday Cafe, as always we appreciate your time when you visit and your wonderful comments! 

If you like what you see here, we would appreciate it if you told your friends (we would love more followers!), if not, tell us. Our goal is to share relevant information that you will use and enjoy. 

And now, it is very easy to sign up for Our Sunday Cafe posts by email. You will find the form located in the left sidebar, thank you for subscribing!

You may enjoy reading about our life and family changes since this blog began, you may find that post here. 

PS, you may also, enjoy our Homemade Household page, it can be found right at the top of the blog!


  1. Experience plus confidence allows us to be completely creative in the kitchen. Your pizza sauce looks perfectly delicious.

  2. Excellent recipe with lovely spices - thank you for sharing. I love recipes that use store cupboard ingredients!

  3. I always have petite diced tomatoes on hand too. Isn't there some law or something about having to buy a couple of cans each time you go to the store no matter how many are in your pantry? I'm printing this one out. Thanks again Darlin!

  4. Love homemade pizza sauce. I have a favourite one but yours looks really good too Melynda. After making homemade for a few years I can't believe I used to buy store-bought. What a HUGE difference. Enjoy your day!

  5. I just bought a can of diced tomatoes today, after seeing Brenda's lovely homemade sauce. Now I've seen yours too! Looks really good. Got to make my pizza sauce soon. My kids are asking for pizza for the past two weeks! :)

  6. I think I need to remember how little it takes to make things from scratch. This really has me looking at my pantry differently. Thanks

  7. Melynda-I always keep diced canned tomatoes in my pantry, because there are so many good uses for them. Most of the time I use it for Marinara sauce, and you are so, so right. Do not drain them.
    Next time I'm in a pinch for the pizza sauce, and not have my usual thick crushed tomato sauce, that I like to use, I will make it your way. Really, really perfect.

    Thanks for sharing. Seriously this is the perfect pizza topping recipe!

  8. I haven't made my own pizzas since I was a little girl, but I keep talking about it! I love your sauce recipe...

    Also, this week I'm hosting a CSN Giveaway at; I'd love it if you entered!

  9. This looks similar to a recipe I've tried. Yum! Love homemade pizza :)

  10. I would never have the guts to try that on my own. I need recipes. Now I have one for your sauce. THX

  11. Without a doubt....the very best recipes come from having to improvise in the kitchen....

    Great post and thanks for sharing at the hearth and soul hop.

  12. This is one of those recipes that everyone needs to know - so much cheaper than buying it! Thanks for sharing your creation with the Hearth and Soul hop.

  13. Hi Melynda,
    We all need a recipe like this in our book. I just love being creative with all the goodies from the pantry.Thank you so much for sharing with Full Plate Thursday and please come back!

  14. Your pizza sauce looks wonderful! Homemade pizzas are the perfect pantry food. Thanks for sharing this with the Gallery of Favorites!

  15. Awesome work that will help me to make pizza sauce at my own home instead of buying from a store with low quality. I think this home made recipe will work great.

  16. That sounds delicious! I had to use spaghetti sauce on our pizza this week since I had been unable to find pizza sauce at our local store. Luckily, no one seemed to mind but this is a great tip to keep handy!

    1. Thanks! What is it about pizza, everyone seems to love it.

  17. Don't ya love canned tomatoes? I keep them on hand for a lot of things - and they are healthier than raw!! Thanks for sharing on the what's for dinner link up.

  18. This sounds great... I love it that we can come up w/ good stuff... because we HAVE to. :) Necessity really is the mother of invention.


Post a Comment

We appreciate your visits to Our Sunday Cafe, and encourage comments, questions, and general conversations! Thank you for dropping by!